I was listening to a talk radio show recently when a caller phoned in to complain about the cost of sending his daughters to college. Higher education, he argued, had become outrageously expensive. But what really seemed to drive his frustration was a specific detail: the university allowed its employees and their children to attend for free.
He couldn’t understand why the institution would give away something others paid so much for. His logic was straightforward: if the university stopped giving away free tuition to its employees, perhaps families like his wouldn’t have to carry such a heavy burden.
It is a completely normal reaction. When costs rise and pressure mounts, the instinctive response is to look around and audit who is responsible for your difficulties.
We see this pattern unfold all the time. When student loan forgiveness became a national debate, much of the pushback followed the exact same structure: Why should people who went to college get assistance that isn’t available to everyone? Why should someone who chose a different path help settle the balance for someone else’s degree?
This accounting system isn’t a modern invention. The impulse to police who “deserves” relief is as old as civilization itself. Over two thousand years ago in ancient Rome, when the government began distributing free food supplies to low-income citizens, working-class Romans who paid for their own meals complained bitterly. The outrage wasn’t just about public funds; it was the quiet sting of watching a neighbor receive for free what you had to labor to buy.
At the same time, society regularly grants targeted advantages that rarely spark the same level of public outrage. Homeowners receive tax deductions that renters do not. Agricultural subsidies support specific growers. Corporate incentives quietly redirect public resources toward particular industries.
For the most part, we accept these arrangements as normal background noise. We adapt to them, benefit from them when we can, or simply view them as the way the world works. But the moment an exclusive benefit is awarded to a group outside our immediate sphere, our sense of fairness sharpens.
The immediate assumption is that fairness means everyone faces the same rules and carries the same weight. But watching that dynamic play out made me remember a time when I held that exact assumption myself.
A few years after college, I was working as a community organizer. During a planning meeting, my boss proposed a campaign to support young single mothers in the area.
My immediate internal reaction wasn’t compassion; it was resistance. I felt like we were rewarding bad choices.
Growing up in Brooklyn, I had been surrounded by temptations that could have easily derailed my life. Friends cut class, got involved with drugs, and made choices that led down hard paths. I chose differently. While others were enjoying their weekends, I was studying or working extra jobs. I traded short-term experiences for long-term stability, believing that discipline was the price of a better future. I graduated with honors, earned admission to a top private university, and built a stable career.
So when the idea of assisting young single mothers came up, an unspoken tallying mechanism kicked in: I delayed gratification and bore the weight of my choices. Why should someone who took the easy route and made bad decisions be shielded from the resulting consequences?
When I expressed a version of this to my boss, his response was brief. He acknowledged my effort and the path I had taken. Then he added: “The children involved didn’t make any choices at all. They’re here in our community, and ignoring them doesn’t make the situation go away.”
I dropped the argument and got back to work, but the reaction itself stayed with me. It took years to understand what was actually happening in that moment.
The shift in perspective came later, through an entirely different conversation with a close friend. She offhandedly noted that I had benefited from a significant amount of privilege in my life.
My initial reaction was defensive. It didn’t match my memory of my own life. I remembered the long nights, the financial stress, buying used clothes, and working constantly. Nothing had been handed to me.
I didn’t think my friend was trying to diminish my effort; I simply thought she was wrong in her assessment. It took some time for me to realize that she was asking me to look at the factors I usually left out of the equation: teachers who took an extra interest in me and pushed me toward advanced classes, parents who provided stability and high expectations, and early employers who saw potential and introduced me to key networks.
I had meticulously tracked every sacrifice because I had felt the physical friction of making it. But I had largely overlooked the supporting conditions because they felt like a natural part of the background.
It turns out there is a well-documented cognitive pattern behind this: the headwinds/tailwinds asymmetry.
Psychologists note that human beings pay disproportionate attention to obstacles. We have to fight against headwinds to move forward, so they register vividly in our memory. Tailwinds, by contrast, carry us along smoothly. Because they don’t require struggle, we barely notice them at all.
This asymmetry shapes how we interpret fairness. When we evaluate our own lives, we do it from the inside—where every headwind, sacrifice, and obstacle is painfully clear. When we evaluate others, we do it from the outside–where we primarily see the assistance they receive or the outcomes they reached, completely blind to the headwinds they faced along the way.
Looking back at my reaction to that community organizing campaign, the objection wasn’t really about policy or personal responsibility. It was about an internal accounting system. Deep down, it felt as though giving someone else a tailwind somehow retroactively diminished the headwinds I had fought through to achieve my own success.
The talk radio caller, ancient arguments over public relief, modern debates over economic policy, and my own pushback against helping those mothers all shared the same underlying mechanics. We build a story of our lives based on what we resisted and what we overcame. When we see someone else granted relief, it can feel like a challenge to the narrative of our own effort–as if fairness requires everyone to face the exact same winds.
We examines perspectives and questions the assumptions behind the stories we tell ourselves, the beliefs we hold, and the decisions we make.




